Need Custom Website?
Finding the right developer can feel like hiring a magician. You’re handing over your ideas, your money, and your deadline — and hoping what comes back is exactly what you imagined. With so many freelance platforms out there, I decided to run an honest test: I hired developers on both Fiverr and Upwork to build small web projects for me.
What I discovered wasn’t what I expected.
Why I Did This (And What I Was Looking For)
I didn’t go in blind. I’ve used freelancers in the past, but I’d never taken the time to compare platforms head-to-head. I wanted to know:
- Where do you get the best value for your money?
- Who’s more reliable?
- Which platform is actually better for someone trying to get a real website built?
For this test, I kept the scope simple:
- A WordPress landing page
- A basic services website for a local business
Both were small enough to be done quickly but important enough to judge quality.
My Experience on Fiverr
Let’s start with Fiverr.
🛠 The Process
Fiverr is gig-based, which means freelancers list what they offer and you choose based on that. I searched “WordPress website design” and quickly found hundreds of results — from $15 to $1,500+. I picked a highly-rated seller in the $200 range with a clean portfolio and promised 5-day delivery.
✅ What Went Well
- Ordering was fast. I clicked “Buy,” sent my info, and the developer got started within a few hours.
- Delivery was on time, and the design was close to what was promised.
- Revisions were smooth — two quick tweaks and it was done.
⚠️ What Didn’t Go So Well
- Communication was limited. The seller followed instructions but didn’t offer much strategy or advice.
- Template use was obvious. It looked nice but felt cookie-cutter.
- Support stopped after delivery. Once marked as complete, they moved on.
🎯 Final Thoughts on Fiverr
Fiverr is great if you know exactly what you want and just need it built quickly. But don’t expect coaching, deep collaboration, or innovation. You’re paying for speed and simplicity — and that’s what you get.
My Experience on Upwork
Now onto Upwork, which works very differently.
🛠 The Process
On Upwork, you write a job post, set your budget, and freelancers apply to you. This took more time than Fiverr. I got about 15 applicants in 48 hours, with hourly rates ranging from $15 to $85. I ended up hiring a mid-range freelancer ($30/hr) with strong WordPress experience and good reviews.
✅ What Went Well
- Initial discussion was more detailed. The freelancer asked smart questions and offered suggestions.
- The build was custom. They didn’t just pick a theme and call it a day. It matched my brand and layout.
- We used milestones. I paid in parts and gave feedback throughout. That helped.
⚠️ What Didn’t Go So Well
- Took longer to start. The first message exchange alone took a day.
- Hourly billing got fuzzy. I wasn’t always sure what was taking how long.
- Higher cost overall. By the end, the $30/hr added up to over $350 for a similar job.
🎯 Final Thoughts on Upwork
Upwork is a better choice if you need someone to think alongside you — not just follow instructions. But you’ll pay more and spend more time managing the project.
Fiverr vs. Upwork — The Honest Breakdown
| Feature | Fiverr | Upwork |
|---|---|---|
| Hiring Style | Gig-based, instant hire | Proposal-based, needs vetting |
| Best For | Quick jobs, small budgets | Custom work, long-term projects |
| Ease of Use | Very easy | Takes time to screen applicants |
| Communication | Basic, structured | Deeper, more collaborative |
| Cost Efficiency | Lower upfront cost | Potentially higher total cost |
So… Which Would I Use Again?
Honestly? Both — but for different reasons.
If I need a quick landing page, a speed optimization, or even a plugin fix, I’d go back to Fiverr. It’s just easy.
But if I’m building something new from scratch, something that needs thought, strategy, and someone who can ask “why” instead of just “how,” then I’ll head to Upwork — even if it costs more.
What I Learned
- You get what you pay for — but not always in the way you expect.
- Fiverr works best for clear, defined tasks.
- Upwork works better when the project is still taking shape.
- Neither platform is perfect — but both are useful in the right situation.
Thinking of Hiring Someone?
If you’re just starting out and want a clean, professional site fast, Fiverr might be the better first step:
👉 Explore Fiverr Website Developers
If you have a custom idea or want to interview and collaborate more, Upwork is probably a better fit:
👉 Find Developers on Upwork
Bottom line:
If you’re unsure where to start, know your goals, budget, and how involved you want to be. That’s the real deciding factor.
Still not sure which platform is right for your next project?
Take this short 1-minute quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your project type, budget, and hiring style.
✅ What to Do Next
Now that you’ve taken the quiz and know which freelance platform fits your needs, you’re one step closer to building your website the smart way.
If your match was Fiverr, you’ll find plenty of talented developers ready to start today — from WordPress pros to Shopify experts.
If your match was Upwork, take your time reviewing profiles and hiring someone who really understands your goals and long-term vision.
Need help planning your site or choosing the right tech stack? Explore more resources at TrillomDigital.com.
Note: Some links may be affiliate links. That means we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase — at no extra cost to you. It helps support our work and keeps the content free.
What about you?
Have you hired through Fiverr or Upwork before?
Share your experience or ask a question below — your insight might help someone else make the right choice.
Leave a Reply